How Auto Insurance Rates Have Changed Over the Past Decades

Auto insurance is a necessity with car ownership. But doesn’t it seem as if paying it always takes a huge chunk out of your wallet?

You’re not wrong. Auto insurance policy prices are based on a number of factors, including your driving record, age, gender, where you live, how much you drive, and what kind of car you drive. If you’re a safe driver and don’t put a lot of miles on your car—or have a car that’s cheaper to maintain—your insurance rates should be lower over time. However, insurance rates don’t just look at individuals; they also look at other drivers and calculate the risk of insuring you compared to them. If the number of accidents in your area goes up over time, the price of your insurance policy may increase too. Cars have also become more sophisticated. Onboard computers with touch screens and heated seats are features that have made cars more complicated to repair, which also factors into insurance pricing. If you presume that you’ll be driving for several decades, it’s helpful to understand just how much costs have changed over time. Cheapinsurance.com collected information on insurance premiums from the Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Price Index data, looking at prices during each decade since the 1970s. The index of insurance premiums is for urban insurance consumers and includes a range of coverage and vehicle types, each weighted based on their importance. Full details on the index methodology can be found here. The 2022 data is only available through March, so the yearly average is based on three months. Prices are not adjusted for inflation since these numbers come from the Consumer Price Index. The data may surprise you.

Though costs may seem high today, 2020 actually had the largest decrease in insurance premiums of this whole period—and one of the very few decreases on record in the last few decades. This was likely due to the COVID-19 pandemic, when businesses closed down during lockdowns and many companies allowed employees to work from home. Consumers cut down on their driving, which led to reduced traffic—and lower insurance costs.However, if you were driving back in the 1980s, you experienced a different reality, as this decade saw the largest percent increase in insurance premiums. Between 1980 and 1989, the average driver saw their premiums more than double.

Read on to see how insurance costs have changed throughout the decades. Find out if you’re better off now or if the “good old days” really were much better.

A line chart showing insurance premiums in the 1970s the values start just about $40 in 1970 and ending at $75.82 in 1979

Matt Albasi // Stacker

1970s

– Average monthly insurance premium: $56
– Premium increase from start of decade: $34 (up 80%)

A line chart showing average insurance premiums in the 1980s. The values start at $82.03 in 1980 and rise to $166.55 in 1989

Matt Albasi // Stacker

1980s

– Average monthly insurance premium: $119
– Premium increase from start of decade: $85 (103%)

A line chart showing monthly auto insurance premiums in the 1990s. The values start at $177.87 in 1990 and end at $253.83 in 1999. Starting in 1997, the sharp upward slope of the line begins to level off and premiums decrease between '98 and '99

Matt Albasi // Stacker

1990s

– Average monthly insurance premium: $225
– Premium increase from start of decade: $76 (43%)

A line chart showing monthly auto insurance premiums in the 2000s. The values start at $256.73 in 2000 and end at $357 in 2009

Matt Albasi // Stacker

2000s

– Average monthly insurance premium: $315
– Premium increase from start of decade: $100 (39%)

A line chart showing monthly auto insurance premiums in the 2010s. The values start at $375.18 in 2010 and end at $571.03 in 2019.

Matt Albasi // Stacker

2010s

– Average monthly insurance premium: $464
– Premium increase from start of decade: $196 (52%)

A line chart showing monthly auto insurance premiums in the 2020s. The values start at $544.63 in 2020, about $26 lower than 2019, and ended at $582.50 in 2022